Rethinking CO2

Why carbon capture will play a crucial role in reaching climate targets and how a CO2 ecosystem can be established

Viewpoint

The potential of the carbon capture utilization and storage market

Addressing climate change led to the perception of carbon dioxide (CO2) being mainly negative. This problem-oriented view concentrates on the elimination of CO2 as a harmful climate gas. Carbon capture is generally viewed critically these days, even though climate scientists point to the need for carbon capture and carbon removal. New ready-to-implement technologies and new regulation offer opportunities in the CO2 market such as the safe storing of CO2 or its use as a raw material in a circular economy. With governments putting a price tag on carbon, but customers also paying to be carbon neutral or paying for CO2 as a raw material, there is an expected market potential for both storage and utilization that might reach oil market dimensions in 2050.

In this report, we have analyzed how to create value from CO2 and what it needs to unlock the German carbon capture utilization and storage (CCUS) market.

Register here to download the study

Key findings

  • 1
    Carbon capture will play a crucial but limited role in reaching climate targets
  • 2
    The CO2 market is driven especially by regulation and technological innovations that increase cost competitiveness
  • 3
    The CO2 market will grow from today’s USD 16bn market size to between USD 43 - 223bn by 2030
  • 4
    Demand for CO2 is driven by permanent storage, synthetic fuels, building materials, enhanced oil recovery and chemicals
  • 4
    To accelerate CO2 ecosystem development, politicians will need to develop a CO2 taxonomy

The role of carbon capture to reach climate targets

As current climate action is insufficient, carbon capture could be one building block to reach climate targets through two roles, based on future emission pathways:

Current policies are projected to result in global warming of around 3°C (above pre-industrial levels by 2100) and thereby making current global climate action insufficient to reach climate goals. The corresponding implementation gap between action and target will need to be filled with building blocks helping to reduce emissions. Carbon capture, as one of these building blocks, can help in reaching climate targets – via two roles:

  1. In addressing the implementation gap by mitigating up to 14% of emissions, especially in hard-to-abate sectors
  2. In removing 20-660 Gt* CO2 from the atmosphere with engineered carbon removal solutions, as natural sinks will not be sufficient

* The IPCC estimates an aggregated need for removal of between 20 and 660 Gt by 2100

The CO2 market potential

Depending on how defined, today’s CO2 market ranges between USD 3bn and 21bn. Despite double-digit growth rates in every scenario to 2030, the CO2 market will fall short of its potential and of what is needed to achieve the climate targets. With regulation in North America and the North Sea states mitigating high costs, carbon capture is expected to take off from 2024. This will grow the CO2 market to a size between USD 43 and 223 bn by 2030 – potentially reaching oil market dimensions until 2050.

While the market growth is driven by the demand for CO2 storage, CO2 utilization might also play a major role.

CCUS in Germany

Especially in Germany - where, for now, CCS is practically forbidden and CCU made unattractive - obstacles stand in the way of carbon capture utilization and storage market development. However, driven by necessity and technological advancements, this is about to change.

With large-scale application in defined areas, the potential CCUS CO2 market in Germany could grow to EUR 8bn in 2045 under the following assumptions:

  • Germany reaches climate neutrality
  • Average carbon capture need of 54 Mt
  • Price of EUR 150/t CO2
  • Annual CO2 direct and indirect (penalty avoidance) revenue
  • Includes both OPEX (incl. energy, operations, transport, processing, storage), and CAPEX (incl. financing, tech, EPC)

What needs to happen to unlock the German CCUS market?

Policy and market participants should approach the following recommendations to unleash the full potential of the CCUS market in Germany:

  • Enable capture in hard-to-abate industries, from air and in bioenergy
  • Open the regulatory framework for national and international CO2 transport/ export for international CO2 storage and integrate infrastructure build-up
  • Enable utilization in terms of a circular economy and CO2 storage i.e., offshore and mineralization storage
  • Create regulatory clarity through enhancing the CO2 taxonomy (e.g., for CO2 origin) & reporting standards (e.g., for CCU accounting, recognition of carbon removals)
  • Create investment and planning security through a framework for (international) market design (incl. carbon removals) and promoting development of international markets
  • Support industry build-up pragmatically (e.g., via ramp-up finance, stimulating pulls, giving incentives, providing funding, and accelerating permissions)
  • Get ready: CCUS is coming - evaluate market potentials and roles internationally and match with actual and future capabilities: decide which part of the value chain to take
  • Analyze and develop a business model, evaluate own project opportunities and decide on a scaling strategy
  • Leverage subsidies and government-backed financing if available
  • Secure partners and long-term delivery agreements – think end-to-end in the value chain
  • Develop the communication agenda and implement a communication strategy
  • If not yet in place: Develop a decarbonization strategy, decide on the role of carbon capture and CO2 utilization in product decarbonization

Erik Schlahn has also contributed to this report.

Contact us

Dr. Johannes Schneider

Dr. Johannes Schneider

Partner, Strategy& Austria

Hide